When Lucy (Beverley Mitchell) tells Kevin (George Stults) and Matt (Barry Watson) that she is going to visit Simon (David Gallagher) at college, the skeptical guys follow her and learn that the real reason behind her visit is to counsel Sandy (Haylie Duff) about her pregnancy and to advise her to stop pressuring Martin (Tyler Hoechlin) to marry her. Meanwhile, Eric (Stephen Collins) has some suspicions of his own regarding Lucy?s visit to Simon, and after spying on her, he also finds out about the pregnancy and Martin's involvement.

Catherine Hicks, Mackenzie Rosman, Nikolas and Lorenzo Brino also star. The episode was directed by Barry Watson and written by Brenda Hampton and Jeffrey Rodgers.