Login or register  
TV
holophonor
(Forum Moderator)

Level 43 (58%)
Posts: 11108
Points: 4362.9
Mood: dizzy
Since: 30/Nov/05
Paige, “All Right Now” – Whatever, judges. She sucked.

Ashley, “Happy” – Um, that was pretty bad.

Janell, “What About Love” – Verging on painful.

Lilly, “Fixing a Hole” – Liked it.

Katelyn, “Oh! Darling” – Liked it.

Haeley, “I Want to Hold Your Hand” – Liked it, for some reason.

Lacey, “Landslide” – No, honey.

Michelle, “Fallin'” – Meh, boring.

Didi, “The Way I Am” – Just OK, but I do like her a lot.

Siobhan, “Wicked Game” – Meh, and she scares me a little.

Crystal, “Hand in My Pocket” – Meh.

Katie, “Feeling Good” – Not so good, but she's so cute.

It was OK overall. Lacey's probably getting the boot, and maybe Janell.
Message Posted On Wednesday, February 24th 2010 at 1:12 am
Hysteria

Level 6 (69%)
Posts: 2006
Points: 118.5
Mood: Hysterical
Since: 11/Jan/06
Nearly every performance was on the verge of awful for me. Maybe I'm exaggerating, but I really wasn't "wowed" by anyone.

Also, I love Ellen, but does she even serve a purpose on this show? I think she's even nicer than Paula, which probably isn't what this show needs. Maybe she would've been better as a guest judge.

And speaking of guest judges...can they at least pick someone with some actual talent/experience? Avril Lavigne, Nick Jonas, Posh Spice...

Ok, sorry for the thread derailing.

EDIT: Oh, and I think Ryan might have made a slight sexual-innuendo joke towards the end...something about "blowing" (he was talking about the glass blower girl)... did anyone else catch this?
Message Posted On Wednesday, February 24th 2010 at 6:25 pm
holophonor
(Forum Moderator)

Level 43 (58%)
Posts: 11108
Points: 4362.9
Mood: dizzy
Since: 30/Nov/05
Yeah, I didn't think anyone was amazing, either. Pretty disappointing, especially since so many people keep saying it's a girl's year to win.

I'd take Ellen over Kara. I'd take pretty much anyone over Kara. All her critiques sound so rehearsed, and she's so dramatic about everything. Ugh, I can't stand her.

LOL, the glass blower joke. I can't remember exactly what Ryan said, but it was an awkward moment for sure. I don't think he meant to make a sexual innuendo, but that's how it came out.

Thanks for replying, Hysteria.
Message Posted On Wednesday, February 24th 2010 at 7:15 pm
Hysteria

Level 6 (69%)
Posts: 2006
Points: 118.5
Mood: Hysterical
Since: 11/Jan/06
You're welcome.

I actually don't mind Kara. She annoyed me more last season, but by now I've gotten used to her.
Message Posted On Friday, February 26th 2010 at 12:32 am
SultanPeppershaker

Level 52 (72%)
Posts: 19450
Points: 831.5
Mood: fubsy
Since: 24/Jan/06
The one with the curly hair, Katelyn I think, reminds me of Lindsey Jacobellis. That's the only impression any of them left on me.
Message Posted On Saturday, February 27th 2010 at 4:32 pm

Quick Reply

UBB code is applied on this message
Show smiley help
   
Warning: American Idol season 9 episode 13 guide may contain spoilers
Recent news

Mel B Talks About Joining 'The X Factor' Judging Panel

Hailing from the world’s best selling female girl group of all time and..

Warner Bros. TV in Talks to Revive 'Full House'

  It has been almost twenty years since ‘Full House’ went off the..

Strictly Come Dancing - Scott Mills confirmed as taking part

Scott Mills is the 10th celebrity to be confirmed as talking part in..