Login or register  
TV
holophonor
(Forum Moderator)

Level 43 (58%)
Posts: 11108
Points: 4362.9
Mood: dizzy
Since: 30/Nov/05
Paige, “All Right Now” – Whatever, judges. She sucked.

Ashley, “Happy” – Um, that was pretty bad.

Janell, “What About Love” – Verging on painful.

Lilly, “Fixing a Hole” – Liked it.

Katelyn, “Oh! Darling” – Liked it.

Haeley, “I Want to Hold Your Hand” – Liked it, for some reason.

Lacey, “Landslide” – No, honey.

Michelle, “Fallin'” – Meh, boring.

Didi, “The Way I Am” – Just OK, but I do like her a lot.

Siobhan, “Wicked Game” – Meh, and she scares me a little.

Crystal, “Hand in My Pocket” – Meh.

Katie, “Feeling Good” – Not so good, but she's so cute.

It was OK overall. Lacey's probably getting the boot, and maybe Janell.
Message Posted On Wednesday, February 24th 2010 at 1:12 am
Hysteria

Level 6 (69%)
Posts: 2006
Points: 118.5
Mood: Hysterical
Since: 11/Jan/06
Nearly every performance was on the verge of awful for me. Maybe I'm exaggerating, but I really wasn't "wowed" by anyone.

Also, I love Ellen, but does she even serve a purpose on this show? I think she's even nicer than Paula, which probably isn't what this show needs. Maybe she would've been better as a guest judge.

And speaking of guest judges...can they at least pick someone with some actual talent/experience? Avril Lavigne, Nick Jonas, Posh Spice...

Ok, sorry for the thread derailing.

EDIT: Oh, and I think Ryan might have made a slight sexual-innuendo joke towards the end...something about "blowing" (he was talking about the glass blower girl)... did anyone else catch this?
Message Posted On Wednesday, February 24th 2010 at 6:25 pm
holophonor
(Forum Moderator)

Level 43 (58%)
Posts: 11108
Points: 4362.9
Mood: dizzy
Since: 30/Nov/05
Yeah, I didn't think anyone was amazing, either. Pretty disappointing, especially since so many people keep saying it's a girl's year to win.

I'd take Ellen over Kara. I'd take pretty much anyone over Kara. All her critiques sound so rehearsed, and she's so dramatic about everything. Ugh, I can't stand her.

LOL, the glass blower joke. I can't remember exactly what Ryan said, but it was an awkward moment for sure. I don't think he meant to make a sexual innuendo, but that's how it came out.

Thanks for replying, Hysteria.
Message Posted On Wednesday, February 24th 2010 at 7:15 pm
Hysteria

Level 6 (69%)
Posts: 2006
Points: 118.5
Mood: Hysterical
Since: 11/Jan/06
You're welcome.

I actually don't mind Kara. She annoyed me more last season, but by now I've gotten used to her.
Message Posted On Friday, February 26th 2010 at 12:32 am
SultanPeppershaker

Level 52 (72%)
Posts: 19450
Points: 831.5
Mood: fubsy
Since: 24/Jan/06
The one with the curly hair, Katelyn I think, reminds me of Lindsey Jacobellis. That's the only impression any of them left on me.
Message Posted On Saturday, February 27th 2010 at 4:32 pm

Quick Reply

UBB code is applied on this message
Show smiley help
   
Warning: American Idol season 9 episode 13 guide may contain spoilers
Recent news

Cast Revealed of New Canadian Drama 'Killjoys'

Space, Syfy, and Temple Street Productions announced today that British..

Kiefer Sutherland & Stephen Fry Reunite for one off Drama

'Sky Arts’ popular comedy and drama strand 'Playhouse Presents…'..

Big Brother UK: Latest Nominations Twist Revealed

The Power Alliance of Ashleigh, Chris and Mark have been outed to the Big..