Although there were 12 songs that the contestants could choose from we only heard 10 of them.
1. Hopelessly Devoted To You - Olivia Newton John
2. If - Bread
3. If I Ever Fall In Love - Shai
4. The First Cut Is The Deepest - Sheryl Crow
5. Can't Fight The Moonlight - LeAnn Rimes
6. I Believe In You And Me - Whitney Houston
7. I'll Never Love This Way Again - Dione Warrick
8. Bless The Broken Road - Rascal Flatts
9. Dim All The Lights - Donna Summer
10. Bat Out Of Hell - Meatloaf
"Crazy Dave", a rather strange contestant whom Paula and Randy put through is eliminated.
99 people made it to day 2
Simon Cowell: So, its the piano, the tonsils and the gland?
Simon Cowell: (To contestant) Ironically, you make that song scary!
Simon Cowell: Back row, congratulations! You are now going home! (Contestants react sadly to the comments)