Don't Trust the B---- in Apartment 23 follows June (Dreama Walker), a Midwestern girl with big dreams when she moved to New York. She is hired at a coffee shop and things go slowly until she meets Chloe (Krysten Ritter), who on the outside seems nice and inviting, but secretly is a swindler who takes June's savings and spends it. However, June is smarter than that and retaliates by selling all of Chloe's furniture. James Van Der Beek (playing himself) and Chloe soon learn that June may be naive, but she isn't dumb.
Chloe than fights back when June introduces Steven as her fiance by sleeping with him. June walks in on them "in the act" and breaks it off. June realizes that even Chloe didn't know it, she saved June from making a huge mistake. Chloe decides to invite June into her colorful band of friends and they go around and be friends. Created by Nahnatchka Kahn (American Dad), "Apartment 23" is a comedy that focuses on the funny world of roommates and what a pain they are until you get to know them.
Following the show's cancelation unaired episodes were made available to view on Hulu and ABC’s website from May 17th.
June and Mark are obsessed with a reality dating show, and Chloe convinces June to go out there and actually get in the game herself. But when Chloe and June end up asking the same guy out, they get sucked into their very own pseudo dating show, with James orchestrating various dating challenges as they compete to win this guy's affection.