Jack and Craig show up at the New York City pawnshop to launch a search for De Grassi, hoping that he will lead them to Rosanna. Meanwhile, unbeknownst to them, Carly and Paul are doing the same thing in St. Barts. Theyre surprised to discover Lucy has also flown there to join them. Craig challenges Jack to find out what Carly is doing while he is away, certain it involves Paul. Jack doesnt buy this, but Craig calls Jacks house and reports the babysitter informed him that Carly was out for the day. Later, Carly, Paul and Lucy are thwarted from getting Rosannas phone records from the hotel clerk. In New York, Jack and Craig recognize De Grassi. Margo has tracked Katie down at the old mill. Mike shows up, too, with Pilars phone book. Katie realizes that Henry spilled to Mike about her call. Mike and Margo warn Katie that she could get in trouble, legally and personally, if she continues to harass Pilar. Later, Mike cautions Pilar that she had better be straight with him and she swears that she is. Henry points out that Katies efforts to get Pilar are pushing Mike and Pilar closer together. A drunken Alison approaches Susan and lies about why she needs her college fund money. Emily and Susan ask Kim not to judge Alison too harshly. Chris finds Alison. He insists that he doesnt want her to pay him back and it wasnt her fault they got taken by the contractor. Alison knows that shes disgraced herself again in Kims eyes and vows that she will make this up to Chris.