A sad JJ is missing Jack when Julia suggests a visit to Santa Claus to cheer him up. Meanwhile, at the Christmas Fair, Carly is disappointed to learn that Jack is having dinner with Julia and JJ later. Nancy presses Jack into serving as a last-minute replacement for Santa. When JJ crawls in his lap, he asks Santa for his dad to come home. Jack is in agony and admits to Carly that having to make a choice between his two families is killing him. Later, Carly tells Rosanna that she loves Jack too much to see him in this kind of pain. She decides shes going to help make Jacks decision easier by signing the divorce papers. Sierra is suspicious when Lucy tells her mother shes decided to take her advice and back away from her search for Craig. Meanwhile, Rafi overhears Dom planning to fly somewhere to take care of Craig personally. He hurries to tell Lucy the news. Later, Lucy tells Sierra that she and Rafi are taking an impromptu ski trip to Aspen. Lucy and Rafi race to the airport to steal Doms flight plan and notify the police of Craigs whereabouts. But, when they get inside Doms private jet, theyre horrified to discover Dom holding a gun on them. Brother Francis confronts Craig with photographs of Cabot, Lucy, Bryant, and Sierra, and asks him to own up to the impact hes had on their lives. Alone in his cell, Craig breaks down as the hidden camera is watched by Sierra! Rosanna confesses to Paul that she said something terrible to Will by practically accusing him of deliberately trying to freak her out. Now, shes convinced the toys and voices were all in her mind because she misses Cabot so much. Later, Will and Paul talk privately about Rosannas vulnerable state and decide to turn Fairwinds into a Christmas wonderland.