On the trip with JJ and Luke, Jack and Holden confront each other about the role Julia has in their lives and how that affects what is going on with Carly and Lily. Meanwhile, Carly and Lily put their plan into motion as they set Julia up in front of Emma, making it appear as if she had stolen the compass Carly once got from Jack. Julia is outraged, but then sees as opportunity, leaving in a huff. Carly is confident about what they have done, but Lily is uneasy. Meanwhile, a crying Julia rushes to the cabin and straight into Holdens arms. Craig reveals to his daughter that he knows she and Rafi made love. Lucy admits to her father that she doesnt know what to do and Craig offers genuine, loving advice. Elsewhere, Rafi and Dusty come face-to-face. Dusty questions Rafi and reaches the conclusion that Rafi and Lucy slept together in the cave. Later, Dusty and Lucy meet and as she begins to confess that she slept with Rafi, shes stunned when he explains that he already knows. While Aaron wants to celebrate the possibility of getting the use of his arm back, Ben informs Bob that a dangerous blood clot is forming and must be removed at once. Soon after, Aaron collapses at Metro and is brought into the ER. Realizing no other doctor can perform the surgery, Bob reinstates Ben who vows that he will do all he can to save Aaron.