Katie and Simon trick Henry into coming over to their house to interrogate him about who he is blackmailing and why. By the end of the day Katie and Simon uncover that Henry is blackmailing Carly for $50,000. Henry admits that Mike knew what he was doing. Katie figures out that Mike is the father of Carlys baby. Meanwhile, Craig rushes Carly to the hospital where they encounter Mike. Mike goes in search of Jack to inform him that Carly is in the hospital. When Jack arrives at the hospital he rips into Craig when he finds out that Craig was there when Carly started having stomach pains. Mike convinces Jack to lay off Craig and to take a walk to cool off. Meanwhile, Emily comes to the hospital and tries to convince Carly not to tell Jack the truth. Later, Carly shows Jack the sonogram picture and informs him that the baby is due in July. Just when Carly thinks that everything is contained and on track she encounters Katie who informs her she will not divulge her secret. Molly realizes after talking to Holden that she has not been a good friend to Carly and promises to be there for her no matter what may come. Meanwhile, Alison tries to convince Aaron not to see Lucy in person but rather through letters which she will gladly deliver to Lucy. Aaron declines Alisons offer. Later, Alison gives Craig the letters she was previously holding on to.