Maddie finds a still, bloody Casey and the slasher. She runs back to the group, who, after Gwen discovers the dead girl wearing her sweatshirt, all accuse Maddie of being the killer. Maddie sobs that Casey is dead and its all her fault. Will and Gwen go in search of a pay phone. Gwen walks ahead, but when she turns, sees Will has been attacked. The other kids find another victim stuffed in their keg. They decide to leave right away, abandoning Maddie. Gwen is grabbed by the slasher. Kevin wakes up at the hospital and remembers that Luke saved his life. Kevin thanks him, and apologizes for what he said before. Liv announces shes going home, and a pouty Kevin tells Luke he might as well go, too. Luke decides to stay. Lucinda expects Lucy to blast her for the matchmaking attempt with Dusty, but Lucy instead thanks her grandmother and says they ended up having a nice time. A thrilled Lucinda assumes theyll be reuniting, but Lucy says that would be the worst thing they could do. Meanwhile, Barbara stresses to Dusty how much of a threat Craigs daughter is to Johnny.