As Lucy and Rosanna try to sort through Lucys memories of the day she and Alison had the argument, Aarons friend Brady shows up. Brady tries to convince Lucy that Aaron did not cheat on her. Lucy tells Brady that he would say anything to cover for Aaron and asks him to leave. As Rosanna tries to comfort Lucy, she gets a call confirming Craigs return flight from Cancun. Later, Rosanna questions why Craig followed Carly to Cancun. Meanwhile, Brady informs Aaron that Lucy was not receptive to his plea on Aarons behalf. Lucy spots something familiar in the pictures as she goes through them. She remembers her argument with Alison and her confession. Chris goes over the events of the fire with Alison and notices that she is acting nervous. Chris suspects that Alison is hiding something. Emily walks in and orders Chris to stop harassing Alison. When Chris leaves, Emily tells Alison that Will is going before a judge today and will soon be home. As Emily leaves, Aaron comes in. He notes to Alison that he has given up on Lucy and asks her if she wants to join him in drowning his sorrows. Jack begins to have second thoughts about kicking Carly out. Molly gets upset with Mike for putting Carlys needs before her needs. Carly runs into Molly and asks if Molly is having an affair with Jack. Carly and Molly go at it. Carly punches Molly in the nose dropping her to the ground. As Mike and Craig break them up, Molly says she is going to see Jack. Carly cries on Mikes shoulder. Mike offers for Carly and Parker come to stay with him. Molly goes to Jacks and tries to seduce him.