Hal and Craig get a report that the kids were spotted in Maryland. At the University of Maryland, the Oakdale Three find a sympathetic student who is willing to give them a place to crash if Aaron dresses up as the school mascot. He agrees and cheers for an ultimate Frisbee game, which Alison and Lucy join. The game exacerbates the rivalry between Lucy and Alison. At Java, Ben questions Jessicas recent odd behavior and she assures him that nothing is wrong. Jessica discovers that Paul had drugs in his system the night Brandy was murdered. Marshall explains that hell refute the report and offers Jessica a deal, which she turns down. In jail, Paul asks Bonnie to stop helping him, but she produces a picture of James dressed up in his Dracula costume and explains her plan to see if someone at the Lakeview can remember seeing him on Halloween. Meanwhile, John and Barbara enjoy breakfast, but are interrupted by James. Barbara manipulates the situation to make it seem as though she and John are together and James threatens both Will and Paul unless Barbara leaves with him. James sees Bonnie get someone to identify that he was at the Lakeview the night of the murder and tells Marshall that Bonnie is becoming a problem. Later, Bonnie goes to share the good news with Jessica, but runs into a frustrated Isaac, who wants her to stop playing detective. Bonnie goes to Paul and he is grateful, but wants her to be careful. Isaac demands to know from Jessica what she and Bonnie are hiding.