Lisa is concerned about how an alliance with Carly will affect Barbaras trial and wants to back out of their deal. Jack apologizes to Lisa for messing up Java when he beat up Craig. Lisa is skeptical, but when Carly arrives and insists that Lisa cant make rules about Carlys personal life, Lisa is impressed and agrees to continue with their deal. Meanwhile, Marshall encourages Brandy to hang around Jack to get more information for him. Rosanna, Craig and Lucy join Aaron and Holden for dinner. Craig asks Aaron if there was any other reason, besides breaking and entering, that Aaron left Seattle. When Aaron stays quiet, Craig reveals photos of a roughed up Aaron. Craig explains that Aaron was beaten up because he was sleeping with another mans wife. Hal consoles Margo when she discovers that she is not pregnant. Tom arrives to drop Daniel off and Emily enters not far behind him. Margo pleads with Hal to help her cover her health concerns from Tom and Hal agrees. In Avanya, Rose tells Lucinda that someone who looked like Simon tried to kill her and Paul. As they try to piece together what has happened, they run into Katie, who is ready to leave. She finds Cooley, who reveals that Simon has the diamond and then dies. Katie decides to stay in town and help. In jail, Simon comes face to face with his imposter, Donovon. Donovon demands that Simon help him pass himself off as the real Simon or hell kill Katie. He returns to Katie, who buys into his scheme until she kisses him and realizes that it is not her Simon.