Luke offers to help Lily make spaghetti for Holden like Rose used to. The scene is a disaster, which ends in an exploding pressure cooker! But the result is a happy domestic moment for the Snyders. Julia confides in Holden her insecurity about her marriage and Jack's doubts about fatherhood. Holden tells her that for him, fatherhood was a surprise, but he was always happy about it. Julia has newfound confidence that a baby will solve her problems. Craig notices he's being tailed by a cop. Carly and Katie clash when Carly catches her trying on the earrings. Craig breaks it up, sending Katie on a "secret" assignment. Carly must "eat crow" and beg Craig to take her back. At the police station, Hal and Jack discover Craig has a connection to Lowe - and thus another to Carly. Hal lets Jack know that Isaac may be willing to work with the police to bring Craig down. Hal and Jack are upset when Shanks reveals Craig spotted him. They suspect Margo may have tipped Craig off and agree to keep her out of the loop. Katie arrives - and is annoyed to realize her important job was delivering invitations to Craig's Halloween party. Hal and Jack decide to go so they can continue to keep an eye on Craig. Back at Craig's, Carly tries to convince Craig that she is back because she wants to be - and she won't betray him. Craig is dubious, but reminds Carly what he has on her. He takes her back, but lets her know that she will be followed. He threatens to ruin her if she double crosses him in order to cozy up to Jack. He informs her of the Gatsby party, which will be the setting for her to sell the microchips - right under everyone's nose!