Jack surprises Julia with an engagement ring and an "official" proposal. Carly heads to Bryant's arraignment, vowing to make him pay. Meanwhile, Craig offers his support, but Bryant rejects him. Lucinda congratulates Bryant for standing up to Craig and tells him he must decide how to plead. Bryant decides to plead guilty to a lesser charge and do community service. Jennifer admits to Bryant that she hates what Hal is doing to him. Craig asks Isaac for a favor - the name of the State's Attorney who can be bribed. Isaac reluctantly agrees, not pleased to hear Craig is staying in Oakdale. Bryant tries to apologize to Carly, but she won't hear it. Hal wants Jennifer to leave, but she declares that she should be charged, too! Carly is stunned when she sees Craig at court to support Bryant - his son! "Lily" and Holden return from the cabin. Holden is rocked when he realizes the photo taken in Canada of Simon and Lily is dated May 26th - the same day that "Lily" returned home. Holden calls Jack, who confirms the accuracy of the photo. Holden admits he believes there are two Lilys! Jack can't believe it, but he becomes convinced as Holden lays out his case. Holden doesn't want to confront "Lily" until he has proof, so Jack decides to take a paperweight for fingerprints. In the meantime, Holden goes to see Mitzi and demands to know why his wife is "a different person."