Alison's kidnapper can't prove that David was behind the order, since Stenbeck was careful to appear uninvolved. Emily visits David in prison, feigning concern for her sister. But when David denies having anything to do with the kidnapping, Emily realizes David just intends to make her life miserable. Things are awkward at first when Jake runs into Molly at the diner, but soon after, she opens up to him about her relationship with David. They agree once this situation is over, they will give their relationship another try. When Hal, Margo and Emily report to Jake that David didn't take Emily's bait, he realizes there's one person who may be able to catch David off guard. "Lily" goes to the police station and pretends she can't positively ID Celia. Jack tells her it's up to forensics in Atlantic City. "Lily" is able to swipe the cell keys and break Celia out of her holding cell. She returns home and vows never to leave Holden again. Officer Shanks discovers Celia's cell is empty. All that remains is a veiled hint: a drawing of a rose and a lily in lipstick on the wall. Lily has a disturbing dream about Holden and the kids and is more determined than ever to leave the island. She confronts Cooley, who offers to give them the missing piece to make the radio work in exchange for one night with Lily. Lily tells Simon she has a plan where she'll pretend to go along with Cooley's demand. Simon thinks it's risky, but Lily believes it's their only chance to get off the island alive.