Jake reveals to Emily and Susan that he has a plan to trap Stenbeck - but it includes letting Stenbeck kidnap Alison! Emily fears if Tom and Margo find out about her dealings with Stenbeck, they will use it against her in the custody battle. Margo and Hal arrive and Jake fills them in on his plan to nail the kidnapper and nab Stenbeck. Susan is reluctant but everyone agrees it makes sense. Margo argues with Emily, realizing Emily thought Daniel could be the target. She lays into Emily for endangering so many. To Emily's chagrin, Susan insists that Margo remain on the case. Jake decides to stay on Susan's couch for safety and offers words of encouragement to a saddened Emily. Holden and "Lily" grow closer as he vows to protect her from Celia and alerts Jack. He admits he finally believes her account of what happened in Atlantic City and she claims she told him she was running off with Simon because she was hurt by his lack of trust. Holden wants "Lily" to sleep with him tonight and she agrees. Faith arrives at the door and the threesome share a tender moment as "Lily" sings to her. On the island, Lily is able to save Simon from Cooley, but is injured in the process. Simon dresses Lily's wound and the sexual tension between them grows. She's excited when Simon shows her the short wave radio, but they realize it's missing an essential part and will never work. A hopeless Lily breaks down in Simon's arms.