Lily and Simon find their raft in pieces and realize that they're not alone on the island. Simon decides to search the island and Lily returns to the cave. She's terrified when Cooley, the wildman of the island, finds her and accuses her of trespassing. Meanwhile, Simon discovers Cooley's hut and an old short wave radio. When Simon returns to the cave, he finds Lily trapped by Cooley. Simon tries to come to Lily's rescue, but Cooley puts a knife to his throat! Back in Oakdale, Jake and Emily settle into their awkward new roles as roommates. Isaac informs them that the word on the street is that Stenbeck is going to kidnap Emily's little sister Alison. At Al's Diner, the would-be kidnapper befriends Alison. Jake and Emily come to warn Susan about the threat. Emily confesses why Stenbeck is after her and Susan tears into Emily for getting them into this mess. Isaac chats with Alison, who tells him about her new "friend" - who suddenly takes off. Isaac tells Jake that Alison has met her kidnapper! Holden invites "Lily" to dinner and she accepts, thrilled. Katie is stunned to discover Holden is going on a date with his wife. Celia approaches Holden at the bar of Mona Lisa, but he's put off by her aggressive conversation. "Lily" arrives and is shocked to find Holden with Celia. "Lily" reveals to Holden that Celia believes they have a priceless diamond that belongs to her. Holden grills Celia, demanding to know if she's involved with Simon Frasier. Celia storms out. "Lily" reveals that Celia is the one who shot at her in Atlantic City. Holden is moved by "Lily's" honesty and vowing to make a new start, they kiss. Celia secretly catches this moment with a camera while a fuming Katie watches from across the room!