Andy is thrilled to discover he can wiggle his toes! Remembering Denise will leave him when he's fully recovered, Andy decides to keep his breakthrough to himself. He even denies feeling anything in his legs when Ben asks. But during an examination, Andy can't hide a reflex and Ben is delighted to see Andy is on the road to recovery. Andy insists he can't feel anything and Ben schedules more tests. John is overjoyed to see his son's progress, but Andy is upset at the thought of losing his wife and child. Simon doesn't reveal to Lily that he has discovered the diamond in her jacket. They go to sleep and Lily awakens to find herself alone. Diamond in hand, Simon has decided to build a raft and leave the island - without Lily! Lily finds Simon and tries to get him to open up to her about what's bothering him. She spots the raft and starts to help him build it. Simon still intends to get off the island - without Lily. Holden is stunned by "Lily's" complete turnaround and holds her at bay. She pleads with him to take her back, but Holden admits he's unable to recognize her anymore and walks out. "Lily" switches to plan B and puts on a sexy negligee and in the hopes of seducing him. Holden almost gives in to her, but he can't, given her erratic behavior. Mitzi tries to convince a defeated "Lily" to return to Atlantic City, but she refuses. Mitzi wonders if her friend is falling for Holden!