When Phoebe Nichols, a popstar named America’s Sweetheart, bursts into flames during a concert, doctor Loman and Horatio uncover that the dead body may not be their real victim. As evidence starts unraveling the case, it is revealed that the singer on stage was the popstar’s double, and now, Horatio and his team does not only have to solve the case of the dead singer on stage, but also find the real Phoebe Nichols.