A famed baseball player is arrested for the brutal murder of his wife. When the jury and defense team make a visit to the crime scene, the room is set exactly as it had been the night of the murder. When the dimmed lights are brightened, the baseball star is found to be killed too, with a meat cleaver stuck in his back and the word "Guilty" written on a note. Horatio believes the defense has messed with the crime scene, making the evidence much harder to gather. Meanwhile, Yelina calls Horatio to inform him that her son, Ray Jr., is missing.