The 1966 case of woman believed lost at sea due to suicide is reopened when her remains are discovered. Meanwhile the trial of the man who attempted to kill Detective Rush begins.
Songs: Ray Charles -- I Gotta Woman, Ray Charles -- What Would I Do Without You, Ray Charles -- What'd I Say
The 1995 murder of an unidentified runaway is reopened when his brother presents proof of his identity.
Songs: Smashing Pumpkins -- Disarm
The team reopens the 2004 case of a teen who was wrongly sent to a juvenile detention center where he was killed and before Valens could make good on his promise to get him released.
The death of a musician in 1970 is investigated and Lilly meets her step-brother Finn who is a teenager.
Songs: The O'Jays -- Backstabbers, The Spinners -- I'll Be Around, Harold Melvin & the Blue Notes -- If You Don't Know Me By Now, Billy Paul -- Me and Mrs. Jones, The Temptations -- Papa Was A Rollin Stone
The 1944 murder of the pilot from the WASP program (Civilian women who volunteered to fly missions for the United States Army Air Core) is investigated.
Songs: Dihah Shore -- I'll Walk Alone, Al Dexter -- Pistol Packin Mama, The U.S. Air Force -- The U.S. Air Force
After uncovering his remains the case of a 45 year old jockey is reopened who planned to retire after a big race.
Songs: Santana -- Black Magic Woman, Santana -- Oye Como Va
The team explores the 1991 case of a 14-year-old girl who died after being sent to a new foster family and was poised to be an upcoming rap music star.
Songs: Mc Lyte -- Act Like You Know, Rob Base -- It Takes 2, Queen Latifa -- Ladies First, Earth, Wind, And Fire -- Sing A Song
The 1983 case of a Chinese-American teenager who was murdered trying to get justice for his slain girlfriend is reopened.
Songs: The Police -- Every Breath You Take, Golden Earring -- Twilight Zone
The case of a champion debater is reopened after a current student from his school shows a letter threatening his life.
Songs: Smash Mouth -- Allstar, Radiohead -- Karma Police, Foo Fightes -- Learning to Fly, Bush -- Letting the Cables Sleep, Fat Boy Slim -- Praise You
The team investigates the 1980 case of a local hockey player who was murdered on the historic day the U.S. national hockey team beat the Soviet Union during the Olympics.
Songs: Bob Seger -- Against The Wind, Bob Seger -- Night Moves
The team re-opens the murder case of a Army recruiter when a soldier he recruited provides an alibi for him. Earlier believed to have been the person murdered for stolen jewelry.
Songs: Gavin Degraw -- I Don't Want to Be, Cold Play -- Potlick
The 1974 murder of a private investigator is reopened after discoveries about his last clients are uncovered.
The 1983 murder of a graffiti artist is reopened and meanwhile Rush, Miller, and Valen's all have personal and legal troubles to contend with.
Songs: The Gap Band -- Let It Whip, Blondie -- Rapture, The Cars -- Since Your Gone, The Gap Band -- You Dropped a Bomb On Me
The team re-opens the 1971 death of a teenage circus aerialist whose fall during mid-act might have been the result of foul play. Meanwhile, Rush uncovers what might be potential charges for another case.
Songs: The Doors -- Light My Fire, The Doors -- Love Her Madly, The Doors -- Moonlight Drive, The Doors -- People Are Strange, The Doors -- Riders on the Storm, The Doors -- Waiting for the Sun, The Doors -- Wild Child
While guest at a wedding the team begins to investigate the bride and whether she was responsible for killing her first fiancé.
The team reopens the case of a dock worker who was moonlighting as an indy-circuit wrestler who was murdered in 1986, and Valens looks into a lead on the man who mugged and raped his mother.
Songs: Def Leppard -- Animal, Bon Jovi -- Living On A Prayer, Bon Jovi -- Wanted Dead Or Alive
After Vera goes missing in an attempt to find him. An arson case he worked in 2006 is reopened and discovered to be the reason for his odd behavior for the last few weeks.
Songs: Pink Floyd -- Comfortably Numb, Pink Floyd -- Mother, Pink Floyd -- The Thin Ice, Pink Floyd -- Wish You Were Here
A recent murder case of Rush's is reopened when a former detective turned FBI agent and friend of Stillman's links a bullet from the crime to a 1980 homicide.
Songs: Tom Petty -- Even The Losers Lose, Cars -- Just What I Needed
Lily and the FBI continue to search for the sniper after discovering his identity and work to protect his next intended victims.
Songs: Dave Mathews Band -- Crash Into Me, Jenny Lewis -- It's a Bad Man's World
The 1969 case of a GI who was on leave during the Woodstock concert is reopened at the FBI's behest. Meanwhile agent Rush and Lily find a mutual attraction they have for each other.
Songs: Donovan -- Colours, Lovin Spoonful -- Darling Be Home Soon lyrics, The Youngbloods -- Get Together, Thunderclap Newman -- Somethings In The Air, Janis Joplin -- Take Another Little Piece of My Heart, The Band -- The Weight
The 1989 case of a prom queen who may have been intentionally killed in a hit-and-run reopened and Rush contemplates her father's requests to give her sister another chance.
Songs: U2 -- All I Want Is You, Mike Reno and Ann Wilson -- Almost Paradise, Aerosmith -- Angel, Young MC -- Bust a Move, Simple Minds -- Don't You Forget About Me, Omd -- If You Leave
Valens and Rush after gaining a lead attempt to rescue Lily's sister. Meanwhile Jeffries tries to bring justice to a mother whose daughter's murder case has remained unsolved for 17 years