Login or register
TV
<-- Previous EpisodeNext Episode -->

Cold Case: Beautiful Little Fool

When a pregnant woman researching her family history comes across disturbing news that her great grandmother, Violet Polley, was murdered and the case was never solved, Lilly tackles the 1929 case, her oldest to date.

While the team is dealing with massive case backlog, they roll up their sleeves and dust off the few notes from the crime which only reveal that Violet Polley was from the wrong side of the tracks and became pregnant by a man, Nick Bartleby, who was considered royalty. Most, if not all, of the suspects from 1929 are either dead or their memories aren't reliable, however, they find the grandson of Bartleby's driver and discover recorded tapes that might lead her in the direction of the murderer. Meanwhile, Lilly's mother, Ellen (guest star Meredith Baxter), announces her engagement and wants nothing more than her daughter to stand beside her during the ceremony.


9/10 (2 Votes cast)

Episode Info


Episode number: 3x19
Production Number: 319
Airdate: Sunday April 09th, 2006

Director: Kevin Bray
Writer: Liz W. Garcia

Alternate Airdates:

FI (MTV3) May 16, 2007
NL (Net 5) Jun 03, 2010

Guest Stars
Meredith BaxterMeredith Baxter
As Ellen Rush
Recurring
Shelley RobertsonShelley Robertson
As Lena
Recurring
Allison MillerAllison Miller
As Violet (1928/1929)
Betty MurphyBetty Murphy
As Docent
Cordelia ReynoldsCordelia Reynolds
As Ginger (1928/1929)
Emily KosloskiEmily Kosloski
As Carmela Bowens (1929)
Gena ShawGena Shaw
As Aimee
H. Richard Greene (5)H. Richard Greene (5)
As Daniel Spyczyk
Jeff NewburgJeff Newburg
As Jeb Shiner (1929)
June LockhartJune Lockhart
As Caroline Bartleby (2006)
Michael C. McCarthy (1)Michael C. McCarthy (1)
As Mickey Stein SR/JR
Nick SpanoNick Spano
As Felix Spyczyk (1929)
Sammi HanrattySammi Hanratty
As Caroline Bartleby (1929)
Tommy DeweyTommy Dewey
As Nick Bartleby (1929)
Episode Notes
Violet Polley was murdered on Christmas Day, 1929.



Music
ArtistSong TitlePlayed When
APMDown In Harlem 
APMThe Jazz Age 
APMAfter You've Gone 
Cast PerformanceOne Dress Left 
Cast Performance300 Flowers 
Ethel WatersTrue Blue Lou 
Fanny BriceSecond Hand Rose 
Five AlarmWriting On The Wall 
Ida CoxYou Stole My Man 
Louis Armstrong & His Hot FiveHeebie Jeebies 
MastersourceThe Wait 
Paul Whiteman OrchestraCharleston 


Analysis
Lilly's phone call outside the restaraunt:

After her heated exchange with her mother, Lilly goes outside and spontaneously calls a man who is never mentioned by name, but considering Lilly's conversation with his machine, it is most plausibly ADA Kite (last seen in Season 1).

During Season 1, Kite aggressively tried to court Lilly, but for reasons not quite clear at the time she always seemed either distant or passive about the relationship. Eventually Kite stopped calling when he figured out that she wasn't ready for a relationship---with him or anyone else.

However, after two years, it is made relatively clear why Lilly rejected Kite's proposals---she was afraid of ending up like her sister Christina (a cheap fling in trouble with the law) or like her mother (an alcoholic who routinely choose the wrong man).

Whether or not Kite makes an appearance in a future episode concerning Lilly's call/confession remains to be seen.


Lilly takes the Polley case despite the backlog of more recent cases because, unlike the rest of the team, she can empathize with the victim's great-granddaughter when she says that the women in her family seem to end up screwing their lives up. Lilly takes this comment personally, considering her upbringing at her mother's guidance and the fate of her sister.



The Walking Dead Season 3 Sneak Peek: Enter the Prison

The Walking Dead's third season is still about five months away, but filming has..

CBS Renews Rules Of Engagement For A Seventh Season

Talk about a straggler. Roughly 95% of broadcast network had its cancel or renew..

Pan Am To Continue On Amazon Streaming?

A couple weeks back, ABC officially canceled the freshman drama Pan Am after a short run of..
TVrage Footer