Garret meets Charlie Davis at a crime scene where a man (her ex-boyfriend) was stabbed 17 times (with a knife from her bar). During the autopsy a bruise in the shape of a stiletto heel is found on the victims body which further points to Charlie as being the killer. Charlie asks Garrett to prove her innocent but that may be hard to do when Detective Framus begins to suspect that Charlie’s (ex)-boyfriend isn't her only victim. Garret performs a live autopsy on Charlie to see if he can prove her innocent or guilty of murder. After the arrival of the exhumed bodies of Charlie's fiancé (who had died a few years ago) and another of her ex-boyfriends (sometime after that), a disturbance is heard in the autopsy room (someone poured acid onto the bodies) just after Garret's record player begins to play the same song Charlie listened to when she was in his office.