  Gus
(Editor)
Level 33 (98%)
Posts: 3532
Contrib Points: 6501.8
Mood: nerdy
Since: 25/Nov/05
   |
|
| Message Posted On Friday, July 21st 2006 At 4:59 pm |
Gus
(Editor)
Level 33 (98%)
Posts: 3532
Contrib Points: 6501.8
Mood: nerdy
Since: 25/Nov/05
|
|
Quick Reply | Quote
|
| On Friday, July 21st 2006 4:59 pm, Gus wrote: | | I've been thinking of getting them. Are they any good? |
To answer my own question, not really. |
|
| Message Posted On Tuesday, June 23rd 2009 At 8:37 am |
 Gadfly
(Global Editor)
Level 54 (32%)
Posts: 1240
Contrib Points: 39559.4
Since: 13/Dec/05
|
|
Quick Reply | Quote
|
|
They're good for what they are. An attempt to capitalize on the popularity of the Daleks, without actually doing anything else from the series (or making it more palatable to American audiences). And otherwise making big-budget color versions of the original material. |
|
| Message Posted On Tuesday, June 23rd 2009 At 4:09 pm |
Gus
(Editor)
Level 33 (98%)
Posts: 3532
Contrib Points: 6501.8
Mood: nerdy
Since: 25/Nov/05
|
|
Quick Reply | Quote
|
| On Tuesday, June 23rd 2009 4:09 pm, Gadfly wrote: | | They're good for what they are. An attempt to capitalize on the popularity of the Daleks, without actually doing anything else from the series (or making it more palatable to American audiences). And otherwise making big-budget color versions of the original material. |
Maybe so but they fall apart when compared to the original serials. Peter Cushing and Bernard Cribbins are very good in them though. |
|
| Message Posted On Tuesday, June 23rd 2009 At 4:50 pm |
Gadfly
(Global Editor)
Level 54 (32%)
Posts: 1240
Contrib Points: 39559.4
Since: 13/Dec/05
|
|
Quick Reply | Quote
|
|
it's been a while. Other then the more comedic elements, and the restructuring of the TARDIS team (obviously "Grandfather Who" and Susie aren't going to compete with the TV show), what in particular is different? Obviously they're not going to wrong as long, but that's not always a bad thing... |
|
| Message Posted On Tuesday, June 23rd 2009 At 10:52 pm |
Gus
(Editor)
Level 33 (98%)
Posts: 3532
Contrib Points: 6501.8
Mood: nerdy
Since: 25/Nov/05
|
|
Quick Reply | Quote
|
| On Tuesday, June 23rd 2009 10:52 pm, Gadfly wrote: | | it's been a while. Other then the more comedic elements, and the restructuring of the TARDIS team (obviously "Grandfather Who" and Susie aren't going to compete with the TV show), what in particular is different? Obviously they're not going to wrong as long, but that's not always a bad thing... |
I don't mind the comedic elements (other than the fact that they could have been funnier). I think the problem was that both times they tried to jam a two and a half / three hour plot into about 80 minutes while retaining all of the major plot points and most of the minor one. This is particularly apparent in Daleks' Invasion Earth. They simply put in far more than can be explored adequately in a film. In my opinion, that makes the whole effort look rushed and bit of a mess. I think that they needed to restructure the script in order to make a good film out of it. |
|
| Message Posted On Wednesday, June 24th 2009 At 4:00 am |
|
Digg
Furl
Del.icio.us
Google