Patrick drinks and watches some videos of Robin. Ephiphany shows up and informs him that she has been looking for him and has covered for him with Monica. She ends up realizing that he has been drinking and tells him he can’t live his life like this. Spinelli and Matt attempt to work out how Lisa died at the pier. Spinelli sees something in the file that makes him think he knows who killed her. Spinelli tells Matt he believes the person is Patrick but Matt refuses to believe it. Matt insists that there is no proof. Spnelli assures him they won’t know for sure until they confront him and that he could be suffering with a post-traumatic blackout. John goes to see Anna and she asks him how he feels about Sonny's verdict. Anna tries to offer him some advise. Sonny invites Michael to the party Kate is throwing for his birthday. Michael tells Sonny that Starr has decided to leave town. Michael picks up Starr’s CD and begins to listen it after his father leaves. Johnny tells Starr that Sonny would do anything for power and there is no line he will not cross. Starr ends up making a deal with Johnny. Jason looks at the paternity results and realizes that the child Sam is carrying really isn’t his. Sam asks him if he will still be able to love the child she is carrying and Jason hugs her.