Connie is able to convince Johnny not to kill Todd. Carly is left feeling spooked by seeing A.J. and passes out. After waking up she goes abd tells Sonny who she saw. Starr learns from Michael that the person in the grim reaper costume was his biological father who was thought to be dead. Duke informs Anna that Luke has reason to doubt him. Tracy sees Monica and Alice sneaking out and knows that they have been lying to her. Tracy tells Luke that she saw Monica looking at an old Halloween picture of A.J. Alan appears to both Monica and A.J. and tells them both how he feels about them. Sonny takes Carly to the Quartermaine crypt as A.J. hides. Carly then realizes that maybe she has just been paranoid. Luke decides to look into Duke's past and travel to Turkey to check out his story. Tracy receives a touch on the shoulder from Alan. Johnny and Connie share a touching moment.