McBain and Caleb are involved in a showdown. Duke attempts to sneak into the Quartermaine mansion but is caught by Tracy. He tells her that he's here to talk to her about Anna. Rafe refuses to give Danny to Heather. Lucy regains consciousness after bumping her head, and sees a vision of Alison. Olivia informs Elizabeth that her brother saved her life after Heather attacked her. Anna fills Alexis in on the details about the real Caleb and his plan to try and reclaim Sam as his deceased wife. McBain fights with Caleb in an effort to stop him from biting Sam again. Elizabeth informs A.J. that she is concerned that Steve won't survive the surgery. Duke hugs Tracy and manages to steal the key and after taking the pickle relish he returns it. Lucy shows with the crossbow to confront Caleb.