The episode begins with Blaine presiding a meeting of a group of students who are dressed up according to their dark side or secret identity. Just then one student comes running and says that the Nationals trophy is missing and someone has left a laptop. There is a video in which a guy is holding the trophy (Warblers) and challenges the club to win the Sectionals. In the hallway, Jake asks Marley out on Friday night; but Ryder interrupts saying that she is going out with him. They then get into a fight and Finn breaks it up. Finn calls a meeting of the Glee club. Some of them are dressed in their super hero/secret identity costume. ..