Marah is with Tony in his office at Infierno. Unbeknownst to her, Josh is sitting in the restaurant with Sam planning her birthday party. Josh calls Marah on her cell phone, but Marah sees that it is Josh and ignores the call. After Tony encourages her to answer the phone, an infuriated Marah storms out of the office and bumps right into Josh. Josh moves off and Marah expresses her frustration to Sam about Tony’s never-ending attempts to please her father. She thanks Sam for being the only person who doesn’t tell her what to do and they bond over Sam’s plans for her birthday. Catalina tries to comfort a distraught Tony who is convinced that he will never be able to please both Josh and Marah. In San Cristobel, Richard knocks out the guard who is holding him at gunpoint and sets off to find Cassie. After a frantic search, he finds a wounded Cassie on the beach, in terrible pain with a sea urchin in her foot. Richard carries her to Mrs. Weymouth’s house where he asks Mrs. Weymouth to help them and she agrees. While hunt dogs bark ominously in the background, Richard tends to Cassie’s wounded foot. Meanwhile, Olivia and Beth try on dresses for Edmund’s coronation. Edmund receives word that Richard and Cassie are still on the island. He toasts the idea that they will be caught soon and then his coronation will go off without a hitch.