Harley finally gets the nerve to tell Frank that Phillip is not the father of her baby, Rick is. Rick is telling the story to Michelle just as Harley is telling it to Frank. They flashback to the night that Harley was celebrating her divorce from Phillip. Harley admits to how distraught she really was and Rick was kind enough to comfort her when one thing led to another. Michelle insists that once Phillip hears the truth about how it happened he will be fine with it, but Rick is more skeptical. Tony is upset that Marah hasn’t asked him to the prom yet and he tries to call her. Sam, after tormenting Tony that Marah hasn’t asked him yet, asks Catalina to be his date for the prom. In San Cristobel, Cassie tries to free the bars from the windows where she is being held captive. Frustrated she tries to write her story on the wall with a nail that she dug up. She manages “Edmund murdered Cassie” and then weak from lack of food and water lays down coughing on the bed. Beth misunderstands Edmund’s concern for Cassie. When she asks what he is trying to say, he realizes he cannot tell her what he has done to Cassie. Beth tries to console Edmund and assures him that she will always love him.