Harley criticizes Beth for using Susan's birthday to win Jim's affection. Beth acknowledges her own bad reputation with men, and amuses Harley by depicting herself as a kind of manhunting witch. Harley convinces her that jealousy of Cassie will interfere with Beth's budding relationship with Jim. Abigail is haunted by a nightmare that she won't regain her hearing permanently. Rick tells Josh that he's afraid he pushed Abigail too far into having the operation. Josh meets with Jim and Cassie, and asks them to be partners at Lewis Oil when he and Reva go on honeymoon. Susan cuts out of school to spend time with Max. They bond over the fact that they've both lost their mothers. Harley learns that Susan is missing, and overhears Susan admit that she misses her adoptive mom. Reva undergoes hypnosis to uncover the truth about her missing years. While hypnotized, Reva visualizes a locked door. Her doctor encourages her to find a key so she can unlock the door. But she finds the memories too painful, and comes out from the hypnotized state.