Frank organizes volunteers from the police department to help search for Susan. After Frank returns with a shoe that was found at the lake, a devastated Harley identifies the shoe as Susan's. Everyone's anxiety is amplified with the fear that Susan may have done something to hurt herself. Frank opens a full-scale police search and orders divers to drag the lake. Holly and Billy grow closer on their fishing trip. Unfortunately, a skunk stumbles across their campground and they're forced to cut the trip short. While dousing themselves with tomato juice, Holly admits to Billy that she faked her fishing skills in hopes of deterring his romantic interest. Billy remains undaunted. Olivia learns Josh fired his lawyer over his exploitation of Reva's sexual past. Josh tells Olivia a story of Reva's childhood that garners her sympathy, but she fears she can never compare with Reva's dramatic life. Later, Olivia learns that her brother Sam has been expelled from boarding school and is headed to Springfield to live with her. Lillian discovers that Beth schemed with Edmund to reunite Harley and Phillip. She asks Beth if she regrets having engineered Harley and Phillip's reconciliation. Beth denies having any second thoughts and reiterates her love for Jim, but remains unsettled by Lillian's questions.