Sam, Olivia's brother, introduces himself to Susan after climbing into the lighthouse deck. Susan shares her problems with Sam, telling him how she hates her parents' spouses and about the party she threw. After hearing Susan's story, Sam urges Susan to return home. Later, she and Jim share an emotional reunion. Holly and Billy have dinner together. Over dinner, Holly tries to comfort Billy about the accident. Holly surprises him with a present and Billy opens the box to find a "singing fish." Billy thanks her for the gift as the two grow closer. After Reva sees a television report on the accident, she begins to cry while thinking of Diego. Noah and Marah comfort her. Later, while pretending to sleep, Reva overhears Noah making a cryptic call defending Reva's presence at the accident and requesting information on the INS in Springfield. Meanwhile, after staying with Josh all night, Olivia allows Marah to see him. Josh awakens when Marah tells him that she loves him. Olivia calls Billy to tell him the good news that Josh is awake.