Phillip tries to bring some Christmas spirit to Harley and Susan by bringing home a tree, but he injures his ankle in the process. Harley and Susan chuckle at Phillip's misfortune and put aside their animosities to trim the Christmas tree as a family. Later, the mood is ruined when Harley chastises Susan for her failure to repay Phillip the money she owes him. Susan notes that her anger stems from her marital troubles. After a visit from Ray, Danny decides to go see Michelle. Danny apologizes to Michelle for refusing to look at their baby's sonogram and offers money to support her and the child. Michelle refuses his money and tells him not to come back until he realizes their family belongs together. Olivia asks Holly to be her maid of honor, but Holly is reluctant. Holly admits that she's still bothered by Buzz's criticism, but Olivia reassures her. While eagerly awaiting Jim's return, Beth is surprised to receive a call from Edmund. Beth tells Edmund that she's dedicated to her family. Later, Beth welcomes Jim home from San Cristobel, but their happiness turns to horror when they realize their Christmas tree is on fire!