Jonathan grabs Reva by the neck and explains that he is just demonstrating how the man she left to raise him treated him. A guilt-ridden Reva calls his bluff, urging him to hurt her if that will make him feel better. Josh walks in, sees Jonathan’s hands around Reva and goes after him. Although Reva protests, Josh angrily throws Jonathan out. Meanwhile, Tammy rants about her humiliation to Sandy, blaming him for impersonating Jonathan and causing him to come to Springfield seeking revenge. Sandy regrets his role in everything and promises to try to make it right. A distraught Tammy leaves and bumps into Jonathan. Cassie and Edmund are out looking for Tammy when they discover Dinah as she works a lonely, heartbroken Danny. Cassie and Dinah clash and Dinah uses the opportunity to drop the news to Cassie about the photo of Cassie that Jeffrey apparently keeps in his wall safe. When Dinah makes a remark about Tammy’s boyfriend, Cassie realizes that Dinah must have known about Tammy and Jonathan and prevented Cassie from finding them in Edmund’s suite. This only makes Cassie more certain that Dinah has her own agenda. Harley shows Bill the pictures she took of the tire tracks from Phillip’s car and reports that the lab has confirmed that they match the tread marks left at the accident. Armed with this, Harley is determined to bring Phillip down but they’re interrupted when an INS agent approaches looking for information on Bill and Olivia’s quickie marriage. Lizzie visits Sandy, who confides in her that he is not the real Jonathan and struggles with his guilt about not being honest with everyone. Lizzie is also torn about keeping the truth about the accident a secret, and is about to confess all when Harley shows up to talk to Sandy.