Harley suspects that Lizzie knows something about the accident. She uses the disguise of Ruth to pressure Lizzie to give up information about Phillip, certain he was the driver. After, Lizzie shares her fears with her father, and Phillip once again promises to take care of everything. Phillip continues to blackmail Billy, who is both panicked and enraged. Later, Buzz and Billy bond over their hatred of the Spauldings. Meanwhile, Coop begins his driving duties for Lizzie, who nearly breaks down. Buzz urges Coop not to stay in Springfield out of obligation, but he insists that he wants to repay his debt and be with his family. The INS decides to pay a visit to Bill and Olivia in order to check on the validity of their marriage - at the same time that Jonathan drops by. Jonathan surprisingly comes to the couple’s rescue but admits he wants a room at the Beacon in return. Later, Olivia and Bill share another awkward moment. Dinah ambushes a shocked Jeffrey, Blake and Ross with an impromptu dinner so that Ross and Blake could get better acquainted with the man in her life. Blake gets the upper hand when she gets a restraining order against Dinah. Later, Blake wants Ross to choose between her and Dinah. Ross picks Dinah and Blake is crushed. Meanwhile, Dinah and Jeffrey spar over which one of them is more obsessed with Cassie.