Nathan and his new officer, Tommy are called to the scene of a murder. According to the footage on the ATM security camera, a hooded man came up behind the woman and killed her with a bolt gun, and then scalped her. Tommy wonders if the killer is Troubled but Nathan figures that it's a human serial killer. Nathan asks if Tommy is regretting moving to Haven but the detective says that's why he moved. They check the footage again and discover that the killer has a tattoo on his right arm just like the one that Nathan has. Nathan says that the tattoo is a townie thing and tells Tommy to take point on the murder investigation. When Tommy asks where Audrey is, Nathan avoids the question...Read the full recap
Nathan: I know what you did. Saved lives, but I know you and I don't trust that'll be the end of it.
Duke: Nathan, I don't think this is about you not trusting me. I think you're pissed because Audrey does.
Reed Harris: Look, I just live around the corner. I just want to go home, get out of these wet clothes, and pretend none of this ever happened.
Duke: It is the Haven way.
Nathan: Do you mind?
Nathan: Do you think she's another victim?
Duke: Or she's the one who started it.
Nathan: Did you deputize him or something?
Duke: Hey, good idea, buddy.
Nathan: Don't call me buddy.