As the meteor storm bombards Haven, Audrey must make an impossible choice: leave with the barn and disappear for 27 years, stay and let the town be destroyed, or kill her son to stop the Troubles forever. Meanwhile, Arla and James are reunited, and the Teagues have a falling out.
Episode number: 3x13 Airdate: Thursday January 17th, 2013
Morning in Haven, and Duke and Nathan arrive at the Grey Gull. They discover that someone has killed Manny, the man Duke had watching Audrey, and Duke figures that Arla has captured Audrey and is looking for the barn. Duke mentions the Troubles going and Nathan figures that he's more concerned about that then Audrey. In response, Duke slaps him and points out that since Nathan can't feel it, the Troubles are still there and Audrey hasn't entered the barn. They try to work out where Arla would have taken Audrey and figure that they would have gone to Kick'em Jenny Neck where the barn left an imprint. However, when they prepare to take Duke's boat, they discover that Arla has stolen it...