The Buchmans' anniversary is tomorrow and, though they agreed they would spend the day alone, they have three lunches planned with friends and family. To avoid another lunch, they lie to Lisa that their anniversary is that day, and the lie only spreads from there. Meanwhile, while Paul is grocery shopping, he realizes he has lost his wedding ring; he does not want to tell Jamie because last time he lost his ring, they had a big fight. Also, Mark tries to get Fran back, but she has moved on.