Becky Freeley returns to her former high school as a guidance counselor. She thinks she has finally conquered the emotional, traumatic side of high school, but she may just find that coming back as an adult isn't all that different.
An attractive new substitute Spanish substitute teacher (guest star Ashton Kutcher) is the object of lust of all the female staff, and he shows an interest in Becky.
A student posts a gossipy blog that stirs up trouble. Becky pretends not to care that she's at the bottom of the "hot teacher" list, but does what she can to raise her sexy status.
Becky wants to be accepted by Tim and Lisa, since they're the coolest kids in school. To fit in, she brings out the rebellious side of herself.
Despite her good intentions, Becky causes an "incident" when she has to plan an anniversary party for a very unpopular teacher at school.
Bruce gives Becky the job of directing the school's high school musical production. Unfortunately, the position requires more creativity than Becky can muster.
Lisa admits to Becky that her marriage is over, but she doesn't know that Becky has a special interest in Tim. Lisa asks her for advice on getting back into the dating pool.