||Toby Cavanaugh, played by Keegan Allen
Keegan Allen plays the elusive and spine-chilling character of Toby Cavanaugh who is one of Rosewood's creepiest residents. Ali accused him of being a perv and a Peeping Tom. Emily, however, can't help but relate to Toby as an outsider. After all, he arrives just as she's questioning whether or not she herself fits in.
Toby told Emily his story – well, part of it. He did see Alison the night she disappeared, but she left him alive (and with his sweater.)
Toby definitely has a dark side (to paraphrase Lt. Col. Fields, he didn’t go away to reform school for nothing.) But he does seem to genuinely care for Emily. We’re torn.
Apparently Alison had some serious dirt on him because he took the fall for Ali's little arson that left his step-sister Jenna blind.