The episode begins with the girls trying to decipher Jenna's Braille message Toby stuck in her book. The characters turn to read "BAD" and the girls wonder if Toby might have been screwing with them. Aria makes a few cracks directed towards Hanna. Meanwhile, Ashley heads to the bank to return the small amount of cash they have left. Hanna points out that Mrs. Potter doesn't need the money anymore and suggests that if it doesn't need to sit in the safe deposit box it should go to someone who needs it. Her mom just wants the whole ordeal to be over. When Ashley leaves Hanna lets Hanna upstairs from the basement. He says he's saving money to go live with a friend in Arizona.
Ashley comes back for a second and almost catches Caleb. Meanwhile, Aria and Hanna make up. The both apologize and realize A is the real bad guy. Ezra meanwhile is shown talking to a few teachers about a book-signing with a published author. Ella is listening and says she might like to come along. The girls meanwhile, give Hanna grief for getting close to Caleb. A man named Nick meanwhile, walks into the cafeteria looking for the swimming coach. He is Paige's dad and he is furious that the school is giving preferential treatment to Emily over his daughter just because she's gay. Ezra intercepts him and talks him down. Meanwhile, Ashley has a meeting with a man named James Leeland. To her shock he claims to be a long-lost relative of Mrs. Potters, her great-nephew.
He wants to look at the safe deposit box and has already prepared copies of his identification for her to present to the state revenue agency. He is an architect. At the end of the meeting he asks her out for drinks. Meanwhile, Paige tells Emily that she didn't say anything about her being gay. Her dad must have asked around. Ella meanwhile, tells Byron he should make sure to meet with Ezra during Aria's parent-teacher conferences. She has lots of good things to say about him and Byron seems a tad jealous. He says something about them getting together that Friday and she mentions going to the book-signing with Ezra. He thought she didn't care for the author. Spencer meanwhile, goes to see Toby, who is leaving for the prosecutor's office. She asks about the "BAD" and he says she's reading it wrong.
He tells her to come back the next day. Spencer meanwhile, gets a text from A that reads "Jenna is gonna be so pissed". Meanwhile, Emily's worried about Hanna talking to Caleb and she says she hasn't told Pam anything about Paige's father. Aria meanwhile, tells Spencer she and Hanna are fine now. Spencer says Toby wanted them to have the message. Spencer realizes that Aria is calling from Ezra's house while she waits for him to get back with takeout. Ezra meanwhile, gets home and makes a comment about meeting Byron. He's a little more worried about that than he is dealing with Ella. Meanwhile, Ashley gets ready to meet James. Hanna clearly doesn't trust this guy. The doorbell rings and it is Caleb. Hanna is stunned and Ashley doesn't like the look of him.
He is polite and ends up coming inside to study. James arrives and is greeted by Caleb. Caleb watches him closely as he signs a form before leaving with Ashley. After they leave Hanna tells him what's going on with James. Caleb points out that for an architect, he used a cheap pen. Meanwhile, the meeting between Ezra and Byron turns contentious. Bryon brings up the fact he's "going out with my wife" and starts ripping the author they're going to see. Meanwhile, the girls are out shopping, and Aria and Hanna tell the other girls what happened with A and the trip to Philly. They tell them how Caleb helped and Hanna says he's been staying in the basement. They meanwhile, see Jenna trying on a lace nighty. She tells the clerk "I want it to be perfect. He likes lace."
Later, Ezra tells Aria the meeting with her dad went terribly. "He hates me or he's crazy." Meanwhile, Spencer looks at the Braille and seems to figure something out. Pam meanwhile, arrives at the school for the parent-teacher conference and Ella fills her in about Nick and his trip to the cafeteria. Pam had no idea. Meanwhile, Toby tells Spencer that for the moment he's not being charged with Alison's murder because the blood evidence was corrupted. Meanwhile, Caleb tells Hanna he's done research on the man her mother is out with. He's using the name of a legitimate architect who died several years ago. Meanwhile, Jenna pulls up at home in a cab. She heard the good news and wants to take Toby to the police station to have his ankle bracelet removed.
He says he already has a ride, grabs Spencer's hand and leaves her standing there. Meanwhile, Ashley decides that saying about the fake great nephew would only draw attention to the situation. She also doesn't trust Caleb. The plan is to show him the safety deposit box and "go from there." Meanwhile, Byron tells Aria that based on the parent-teacher conference meeting; he thinks Ezra is a lightweight. Aria defends him but Byron isn't having it. He lets slip that Ella is part of the situation and Aria tells him the thing Ezra is taking her too is being attended by half the department. Meanwhile, when Ashley opens the box James is clearly surprised to only see $3,000 in there. When he starts fishing about the possibility that the money was stolen Ashley makes a reference to his bank in Syracuse that, lets him know she might know he's full of it.
He smiles. Meanwhile, Pam comes to school and asks Emily if the story about Blaine's father is true. Emily says she didn't think her mother would defend her. Pam promptly turns to Paige's father and threatens that if he doesn't drop this crusade "I'll show you what a real agenda looks like." Afterwards a weepy Pam tells Emily she loves her and apologizes. Meanwhile, Toby and Spencer end up at a lookout point-type area overlooking the city. She's figured out that the Braille symbols actually spelled out 214 but doesn't know what it means. He doesn't either, saying only that he overheard Jenna talking about Spencer to someone and made a rubbing of what she wrote. He thinks they need to find out what she's up to and says he doesn't trust his sister. He thinks Jenna is afraid of Alison's friends.
Meanwhile, Emily gets in her car to drive home. Paige jumps in the passenger seat and says Pam was right about her dad. When Emily starts complaining how tough her life is at the moment Paige leans over and kisses her deeply. She then says "don't tell" and jumps out of the car. Meanwhile, Caleb makes a comment about perhaps not being in a huge hurry to leave for Arizona. She thanks him and they stare at each other before he heads downstairs. There is a knock at the door. It's an exterminator who has gotten a call from someone named "A" about "infestations in the basement." Hanna gets rid of him but realizes what's happened.
Ezra and Aria meanwhile are busy making out on his couch. The phone rings with a call from Byron. He's read some of Ezra's stories and wants to have a beer with him. Spencer and Toby meanwhile, drive past a motel. The camera zooms in to focus on room 214. Meanwhile, someone is shown laying flowers at the gravestone of Mrs. Esther Marie Potter. The episode ends at this point. Share this article with your friends