Guest Stars

Annabeth Gish As Dr. Anne Sullivan Recurring	Brendan Robinson As Lucas Gottesman Recurring
Janel Parrish As Mona Vanderwall Recurring	Keegan Allen As Toby Cavanaugh Recurring
Lindsey Rachel Shaw As Paige Recurring	Nia Peeples As Pam Fields Recurring
Tammin Sursok As Jenna Marshall Recurring	Torrey DeVitto As Melissa Hastings Recurring
Tyler Blackburn As Caleb Recurring

Recap

The scene opens with the girls watching a TV report on the case against Garrett, which seems to be based on the missing page of the autopsy report. Melissa walks in acting strange and says if Garrett killed Alison there was a reason. Emily gets text from A saying if they don't bring the "something that belongs to me" one of them will die; visibly scaring everyone in the process. They assume this is a reference to the phone. A messenger delivers invitations for a costume-required "Masquerade Ball" held by the Rosewood Junior Society. A wants to play hide-and-seek, telling them to be there at midnight, if they know what’s good for them. The girls seem intimidated by going against Melissa's brains if she is in fact A; they do not want to seem to take a chance. ..

Read the full recap