Things get tense when the six friends gather together to celebrate Thanksgiving 1992. Aaron’s date is co-worker Rachel, whom he doesn’t realize has an ulterior motive for wanting to come. Jenna’s movie-star husband joins her and it becomes obvious that this may be a marriage of convenience. Will brings his girlfriend Vanessa, his former Army buddy’s sister, but does he still have feelings for Samantha? And Russell Brewster shows up and demands that Will be thrown out, still blaming him for the collapse of the Brewster Group. Meanwhile, in the present day, Detective Marjorino’s 20-year obsession for revenge against his father’s killer and now the investigation of Samantha’s murder is taking a toll on his marriage.