Paul heads to Washington to further investigate the key that Tannen gave him. Henry looks into getting fake IDs for the family.
To help Brady be eligible for the upcoming homecoming football game, Hannah swaps one of his English papers for one of her old ones. However, Hannah's plan backfires when Brady is accused of plagiarism.
Gina tells Paul and Lily that she's hiding from her abusive ex. Meanwhile, Henry begins to warm up to Randy, but his trust is short-lived when Randy puts Henry and Jake in danger. Elsewhere, Hannah and Amber go to a frat party.
In this episode Kylie and Henry agree to meet up in St. Louis, unaware that the FBI has followed Kylie. Meanwhile, Hannah and Brady share a kiss after he confesses his feelings for her.
Henry's girlfriend Kylie calls his secret number on US marshal instructions. When dad scolds him irresponsible and immature, he bitterly bites back he saw him kiss Erin a year ago, on anniversary day. Working out his memory proves a vital clue. helped by Gina, they shake off the marshals and find the probable killer is Cunningham. Meanwhile Susie hesitates to go steady with Brady, even after he and Amber agree to break up, because of her own past back home.