Sabrina, Morgan and Roxie arrive in New York to so Morgan can interview Course of Nature on TRL after winning a contest that was put on by Scorch magazine. It doesn’t take long for her to admit that she stole one of Sabrina’s articles for the contest that ultimately gets Sabrina a job at the magazine. Meanwhile, when Salem stows away on the girls’ trip, he finds the streets of New York to be pretty harsh, especially after having a run in with a city rat. Upon their arrival home, Sabrina invites Morgan and Roxie to move in with her.
Sabrina gets her first big assignment - she has an interview with one of the most unfriendly pop-stars, but when she takes the advice of a co-worker and tells the world just how horrible the guy really is, he vows that she either makes a live apology at his next concert, or lose her job.
When Sabrina tries too hard to impress her new co-workers at Scorch, they begin to think she’s crazy after the amount of gloating she does regarding her magical exploits. It is only after she has a chance meeting with Ashanti that Sabrina is given an opportunity to show them how mature and professional she is.
After learning she has to interview a Hip-Hop diva with a nasty reputation, Sabrina becomes so intimidated that she almost asks Annie to have someone else do it. However, after taking Salem’s advice about putting her under a spell, Sabrina was able to get her interview done, only to learn later that she swapped personalities with the Hip-Hop star. In order to reverse the spell, Sabrina has to turn to an Other Realm Spell-Checker for help.
After learning that a famous actress is a kleptomaniac, Sabrina becomes determined to write an article about it for her magazine. However, when she thinks up a plan to catch her in the act, it is Sabrina who gets in trouble with the cops. However, Sabrina thinks she is able to continue with her story when she is able to get the actress to admit she framed Sabrina in the boutique on national television, only to learn about all of her secrets that are bigger than her shoplifting problem.
When Sabrina finds out that Leonard set up a series of web cams to catch what goes on behind the scenes at the magazine, she promptly protests his plans. After she does magic in an area she thought didn’t have a web cam set up in, Sabrina becomes mortified at the prospect of being found out as a witch and decides to zap herself into Leonard’s computer to edit that part of the video out. While there, she has a run-in with Scooby-Doo and Shaggy before getting stuck in the computer for the night. The next morning however, when Leonard sees Sabrina in his computer, he begins to change her into a Jessica-Rabbit look-a-like. After she zaps herself out of the computer, several people begin to treat her like a dingy blonde because of her looks, ultimately making her mad and almost costs her an interview with a musician that both Morgan and Roxie has a crush on.
One night at work, Sabrina unknowingly uses her magic in front of Victor, a smooth talking gallery owner. When she decides go to a party with him instead of going out with Roxie and Morgan, the girls have a falling out that almost keeps Roxie and Morgan from saving Sabrina when she realizes that Victor wants to add her to his collection of mythical creatures. After they realize she is in trouble, Roxie and Morgan go over to Victor’s place with Harvey to save Sabrina. After being rescued, Sabrina is able to send Sasquatch, the Leprechaun, and mermaid back to their homes and then thanks her friends for helping her out.
After Avril Lavinge does a special performance at a local club, Sabrina meets a local musician who plays at the same club. It is during an interview that Sabrina begins to suspect that the club owner is blackmailing him into only playing there, and begins investigating the man’s actions. However, when she gets threatened by him, Sabrina starts to fear she will be met with an untimely death at his hand. It is after she goes into the future with Salem and Amanda that Sabrina learns that the reason why she dies so young isn’t due to the club owner’s threats, but as a result of second hand smoke that happens as a result of Amanda’s smoke-filled magical entrances.
When Sabrina, Roxie, and Morgan go to Miami with Leonard to celebrate Christmas, they have a run in with Roxie's mother at their time share. However, when their place gets robbed, Candy gets accused, ultimately leaving Sabrina and Morgan to help Roxie clear her mother of the charges. Meanwhile, when Leonard finds out that Sabrina brought Salem along to the condo, he tells her to put him the condo’s kennel, where Salem complains about being treated like an “animal,” and Morgan is crowned “Miss Wet Christmas.”
After seeing a commercial for a nationally televised talent show announcing auditions for its upcoming season, Sabrina talks Roxie and Morgan into forming a girl band with her so she can get an inside story about the experience to write about for her magazine. However, it doesn’t take long for the girls to realize that they’re going to be the untalented act trying out so Sabrina decides to use her magic to make them talented enough to be a finalist in the contest. Unfortunately, the side affects of the magic lozenge makes the girls’ egos so large that their friendship might fall by the wayside as a result. With a lot of help from Harvey, Sabrina is able to get Roxie and Morgan out of the spotlight and ultimately break the spell over her friends.
When Sabrina finds out that Annie assigned her the task to interview British Pop Star Daniel Beddingfield, she happily tells Morgan about the spread Scorch plans to do on him. After she learns that Annie needs a designer to outfit the singer for the photo shoot, Sabrina promptly tells her about the great fashion designs Morgan came up with and is able to land her friend the job. However, when everybody at the magazine sees how bad Morgan’s work is, they designate Sabrina to be the one to fire her. However, when she attempts to do so, Morgan gets mad at Sabrina for lying to her when she first told her clothes were great. They ultimately patch thing up on Roxie’s radio show as Daniel sings one of his songs.
Because she hasn’t used much magic since Roxie and Morgan moved in, Sabrina learns from Louisa that the house is has to go through a magical systems check. It is when she is talking to the wall that she begins to worry about how Roxie feels she is keeping secrets from her and Morgan. To make matters worse, Roxie begins to have a hard time trusting her when Sabrina accidentally lets it slip to Morgan about how she having a tattoo removed. Sabrina was then able to find a spell that will help with having Roxie trusting her with blind faith. Things work well for a while, but after the entire neighborhood begins to put all their trust into Sabrina, she gets a notice to appear before a judge in the Other Realm about spell she enacted. Sabrina then learns that in order to reverse it, she has to reveal her secret to Roxie, only to have her not believe it.
When Sabrina meets a cute guy named Aaron at the office, she begins to wonder why she continually runs from him every chance she gets. Curious to find out why she is hesitant to get close him, Sabrina turns to her magic book for help. However, when she arrives home, Sabrina gets a little surprise at seeing Salem with a white rabbit that he would like to keep as a pet. After she finds a spell that can help her find out what makes Aaron tick, Sabrina gets taken on a wild ride through Wonderland, where she learns a few truths about why she has been acting so strangely around guys she’s interested in.
Tiring of her clumsy ways at home and work, Sabrina decides to use her magic to become the perfect person. While the spell turned Sabrina into a mistake free individual, there were some consequences that came along with it that ultimately makes her a know-it-all. As a result, Sabrina almost looses her job at Scorch, as well as her friendships with Roxie and Morgan because of the bad finance advice she gave them. It is only after Sabrina attends a class in the other realm that she realizes being clumsy and making mistakes are all apart of life that aids in making people better individuals in the long run. Upon returning to the office, Sabrina decides to stand up for herself and tells Annie that she’s quitting in order to become a freelance writer.
After trying unsuccessfully to balance the things in her life, Sabrina’s room turns into a circus tent. Upon talking to the ringmaster, Sabrina learns that in order for things to return to normal, she has to walk a tightrope above her bed until finding the balance between spending time with Aaron, her friends, and Harvey. It was through the course of these events that Sabrina learns that Harvey is still in love with her.
Wanting to tell Aaron that she loves him at dinner, Sabrina suddenly has a hard time finding enough nerve to say what’s in her heart. The next day however, she decides to call upon her own private Cyrano to help tell Aaron her feelings, only to become dismayed to learn that after Aaron spends an afternoon with Cyrano and that he begins to have feelings for her. When Sabrina learns that Cyrano Sarah kissed her man and intends to keep him for herself, she takes matters into her own hands and the girls begin fighting over Aaron, which results in Sabrina proclaiming her feelings for him. Meanwhile, when Harvey goes to see Roxie and Morgan, he admits to them that he still is in love with Sabrina.
After Sabrina uses her magic to save Morgan from falling down an elevator shaft, she makes the three Fate goddesses furious. After they vow revenge on her, Sabrina begins thinking of ways to get back in their good graces, only to make her life, and that of Aaron’s more chaotic. Meanwhile, Morgan has an epiphany following her near-death experience and decides to help Roxie with her environmental club's next protest.
When Aaron and his parents have dinner at Sabrina's, Salem tries to ruin the night by inviting Harvey. Things get worse for Sabrina when she inadvertently blurts out that she loves Harvey, not Aaron. To make up for it, Sabrina goes inside of her heart to find out why she said what she did.
After going to a bridal fair, Sabrina decides to have a princess wedding. After contacting Cinderella for help planning it, she quickly becomes a monster with the way she went overboard in planning. After realizing what she has done, Sabrina decides to forgo the elaborate plans and goes along with Morgan and Roxie’s wedding plans, after reluctantly put aside their differences to plan Sabrina’s bridal shower.
When Aunt Irma pays Sabrina a surprise visit before her wedding, Sabrina tries to conceal the fact that Aaron is a mortal. However, when Harvey shows up and tells Irma that he isn't a witch, she turns Aaron into a fish. Ultimately, Sabrina and Harvey are able to change Aaron back into a human. While this is going on, Roxie and Morgan are interviewing potential roommates to move into the house after the wedding.
When Sabrina, Roxie, and Morgan go on a bachelorette cruse to Bermuda, they learn if their friendship can handle what life throws at them, with the help of unexpected friend. While they are gone, Aaron stays at Sabrina's, cat sitting Salem, only to get into a fight with the feline.
-- Holla Back
When Sabrina wakes up on the morning of her wedding, she unsuccessfully tries to hide her wedding day jitters, especially after Doubt shows up. She then goes to the moon to locate Aaron’s soul stone to see if it’s a perfect fit to hers. However, Sabrina soon gets some moral support when Aunt Hilda and her mother arrive with Zelda in candle form to try and help her out. All it takes to help Sabrina get rid of her doubt is Amanda to invite Harvey to the church to talk to her.