Wanting to set Valerie up with a team mate of Harvey’s, Sabrina turns to Cupid to get the teenagers interested in one another. Meanwhile, after getting into trouble with Mr. Kraft over an article she wrote for the newspaper, Sabrina attempts to set Hilda up with him to get out of a possible date with detention. When she fails, Sabrina calls Cupid back to make her aunt fall in love with Mr. Kraft, only to learn that she needs Hilda’s consent to be put under his love spell. She soon becomes desperate and puts a “dummy” spell on Hilda to get her out on a date with her vice-principal. After being found out at the restaurant, Sabrina is taken by an angry Hilda to the Other Realm to have Zelda punish her.