After learning that on Friday the 13th witches can tell their mortal friends about their magical powers, Sabrina gets happy at the prospect of telling Harvey and Valerie her secret. Before she does however, Hilda and Zelda warn her about the consequences of doing so, but Sabrina feels it is worth the risk. Unfortunately, when Sabrina reveals her secret to them, she is unaware Libby also heard it and decided to spill the beans to the PTA and media. After spending the day together in the Other Realm, where Valerie gets to dance with Drew Carey and Harvey meets Mark Langston, Sabrina has to face Libby’s charges of witchcraft. Thanks to Valerie and Harvey not remembering the day’s events upon their arrival back at the Spellman home; Libby promptly begins looking like a liar, starved for any attention she could get.