When Sabrina starts getting her college acceptance letters, she finds herself in a difficult situation: trying to make Harvey, Hilda, Zelda, and Josh happy by choosing the life paths they want her to go down. As a result, Sabrina gets torn in four different directions and each part of her finds the different people to surprise them with Sabrina’s decision. Things come to a head when each Sabrina invites them all to the prom and everybody starts arguing over who got invited by Sabrina. Things eventually get straightened out when the four parts of Sabrina confront their true feelings over where they want to go to school. As a result, each part becomes one Sabrina again and she promptly goes back into the gym to let her aunts, Harvey, and Josh know where she plans on going to college.