While on her shift at the Coffee House, Sabrina has a run-in with Derek, an old boyfriend. After spending a little bit of time looking at some of Derek’s paintings, he and Sabrina share an unexpected kiss. Disappointed with the way Josh reacted he finds out, Sabrina follows Salem’s advice to go to an Other Realm romance novelist for advice on getting a more passionate response from him. However, after several failed attempts to get the desired jealousy out of Josh, Sabrina learns from Francesca that the original way Josh reacted to the news was the way he was supposed to act. As this is happening, Hilda and Zelda are organizing a charity auction to benefit the local library.